Justia California Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries
S.N. v. Fresno Unified School Dist.
A former elementary school student brought a lawsuit against a school district, alleging that she was sexually abused by her teacher during her time as a student. The complaint included claims of negligence and negligent hiring, retention, and supervision, asserting that the district was aware of prior allegations against the teacher, had settled an earlier lawsuit involving similar misconduct, and failed to take adequate action to protect students. The plaintiff claimed the abuse occurred both on and off school property, including during rides home with the teacher.The Superior Court of Fresno County granted summary judgment in favor of the school district, finding the district immune from liability under Education Code section 44808 because, based on the plaintiff’s deposition, the abuse occurred off school property and after school hours. The trial court also excluded certain evidence offered by the plaintiff, such as police reports and documents intended to show the district’s notice of the teacher’s dangerousness, on grounds of hearsay and lack of authentication, and found that the plaintiff’s efforts to cure these evidentiary defects were untimely.The California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, reversed the summary judgment. The appellate court held that Education Code section 44808 does not provide immunity to a school district when it has failed to exercise reasonable care under the circumstances, regardless of whether the resulting injury occurred on or off campus. The court concluded that the district’s motion only addressed the location and timing of the abuse, not whether the district exercised reasonable care or whether any failure of care caused the plaintiff’s injuries. Because the district did not meet its initial burden for summary judgment, the judgment was reversed and remanded for further proceedings. View "S.N. v. Fresno Unified School Dist." on Justia Law
Moffett v. Lake Merritt Healthcare Center
Paris Moffett, a young man who was paralyzed after being shot, was admitted to a skilled nursing facility owned by Lake Merritt Healthcare Center, LLC. In March 2023, Paris signed an arbitration agreement with the facility, which stated it would bind not only Paris but also his representatives and family members. Days later, Paris was fatally shot by intruders who entered the facility through an unlocked door. Paris D’Marco Moffett, Paris’s father, filed suit against the facility and its owner, asserting four causes of action: negligence, negligent abuse of a dependent adult, a claim for extreme pain suffered by Paris before death, and wrongful death. Paris’s father did not sign the arbitration agreement.The Alameda County Superior Court reviewed a motion by the defendants to compel arbitration of all claims. The court denied the motion, mainly because Paris’s father had not signed the arbitration agreement. The defendants appealed, arguing that all claims should be arbitrated based on the agreement signed by Paris.The California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District, Division One, considered the appeal. It held that the wrongful death claim could not be compelled to arbitration because it was brought in Paris’s father’s personal capacity, and he did not agree to arbitrate. The court clarified that, under California law, wrongful death claims are independent statutory actions, not derivative of the decedent’s claims, and an exception that allows binding heirs to arbitration applies only in cases of medical malpractice, not elder or dependent adult abuse. However, the court found that the three survivor claims—negligence, negligent abuse of a dependent adult, and pain and suffering—were subject to arbitration, as they belonged to Paris and survived his death. The court affirmed denial of arbitration for the wrongful death claim but reversed as to the survivor claims. View "Moffett v. Lake Merritt Healthcare Center" on Justia Law
Doe v. The Maybourne Beverly Hills Operator, LLC
A former guest reception manager at a luxury hotel in Beverly Hills alleged that, after disclosing her pregnancies, she experienced a pattern of workplace harassment based on her sex, gender, and pregnancy. She described being subjected to comments about her ability to work as a mother, being denied advancement opportunities, and ultimately being falsely accused of inappropriate sexual conduct before her termination. The complaint also alleged that women at the hotel were generally treated less favorably than men and were undercompensated.Following her termination, the plaintiff filed suit in the Superior Court of Los Angeles County, raising claims under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) for harassment, discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination. The hotel operator sought to compel arbitration based on a preexisting arbitration agreement governed by the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA). The plaintiff opposed the motion, arguing that her claims arose from a “sexual harassment dispute” covered by the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021 (EFAA), which renders predispute arbitration agreements unenforceable at the plaintiff’s election in such cases. The Superior Court denied the motion to compel arbitration, holding that her allegations met the definition of sexual harassment under California law and thus fell within the EFAA’s exception.The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Seven, reviewed the case. It affirmed the lower court’s order, holding that the EFAA’s exception for “sexual harassment disputes” is not limited to lewd or lascivious conduct, but extends to gender- and pregnancy-based harassment as recognized under FEHA. The court concluded that the plaintiff had adequately alleged a hostile work environment based on gender and pregnancy, and thus the EFAA precluded enforcement of the arbitration agreement. The order denying arbitration was affirmed. View "Doe v. The Maybourne Beverly Hills Operator, LLC" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Arbitration & Mediation, Labor & Employment Law
Banuelos-Hernandez v. Super. Ct.
The petitioner was charged with driving under the influence and driving with a blood-alcohol content of 0.08 percent or more. After arraignment and a series of hearings, the petitioner filed a motion to suppress evidence. The prosecution requested continuances at two separate hearings, both of which the petitioner opposed. On the second occasion, after denying the prosecution’s oral request for a continuance due to lack of good cause, the Superior Court of Contra Costa County dismissed the case because the prosecution was not ready to proceed. Later that same day, the court recalled the parties, stated it had made a mistake, and retracted its dismissal, citing a belief that the dismissal was an abuse of discretion.The petitioner then sought a writ of mandate from the appellate division of the Superior Court of Contra Costa County, which was denied. The petitioner subsequently filed a writ petition with the California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District, Division Five. The prosecution argued that the court’s dismissal was unauthorized, interim in nature, and could be retracted, or alternatively, that their response should be construed as a writ petition challenging the denial of the continuance.The California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District, Division Five held that the trial court had discretion to dismiss the criminal action under Penal Code section 1385, even without expressly invoking the statute. The appellate court found that once the trial court dismissed the entire criminal action, it lost jurisdiction to retract or modify that dismissal, even if the order was reached in error or constituted an abuse of discretion. The appellate court directed the issuance of a peremptory writ of mandate compelling the trial court to vacate its order retracting the dismissal. View "Banuelos-Hernandez v. Super. Ct." on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
P. v. Gardner
The defendant was charged with robbery after he entered a store, selected several items, and attempted to leave without paying. When confronted by a store clerk, he brandished a machete to force her out of his way before fleeing and being apprehended nearby. He had a recent history of similar offenses, many involving the use or threat of weapons such as a hammer, screwdriver, and axe, often directed at persons during thefts. The defendant was diagnosed with schizophrenia and substance use disorders, and had previously completed a court-ordered treatment program but stopped taking his medication afterward.The Superior Court of Los Angeles County reviewed his petition for pretrial mental health diversion under Penal Code section 1001.36. Although evidence showed he met the eligibility requirements for diversion, the court denied the petition. The court based its decision on findings that the defendant was unlikely to consistently take his medication and posed an unreasonable risk to public safety, given his repeated use of weapons and threats of violence during crimes. The defendant then pled no contest to robbery and was sentenced to two years in prison.On appeal, the California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Four, considered whether the trial court erred in denying the mental health diversion petition. The Court of Appeal held that the trial court did not abuse its discretion. It found substantial evidence supported the conclusion that the defendant was highly likely to commit a “super strike” offense, such as murder or attempted murder, if not closely supervised and medicated, based on the nature and escalation of his prior offenses. The appellate court affirmed the judgment of the Superior Court, upholding both the denial of diversion and the sentence. View "P. v. Gardner" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
Bakersfield Crisis Pregnancy Center v. Dept. of Managed Health Care
A group of plaintiffs, including a nonprofit pregnancy center and two physicians, brought a taxpayer action challenging the constitutionality of the Abortion Accessibility Act of 2022 in California. This law prohibits health insurance plans from imposing cost-sharing requirements such as deductibles and copays for abortion and abortion-related services, while allowing such cost-sharing for prenatal and maternity care for those who continue a pregnancy. The plaintiffs argued that this statutory scheme violated the right to reproductive privacy and the right to equal protection for women who choose to carry their pregnancies to term.The Superior Court of Kern County conducted a two-day court trial, during which both sides presented expert and factual witnesses and stipulated to several key facts about costs and insurance coverage. The trial court found that the plaintiffs failed to prove the Act either encouraged or coerced women into having abortions, or that it interfered with women’s ability to exercise their constitutional right to choose whether to have an abortion or continue a pregnancy. The court concluded that the plaintiffs had not established a “serious invasion” of privacy or a significant interference with a fundamental right. As a result, the trial court applied the rational basis standard to the equal protection claim and found a rational legislative purpose for the distinctions made by the Act.On appeal, the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Fifth Appellate District, reviewed the legal standards applied and the allocation of the burden of proof. The appellate court affirmed that strict scrutiny did not apply because no significant impairment of a fundamental right was proven. It held that the Act did not violate the right to privacy or equal protection under the California Constitution, as the law’s classifications were rationally related to the legislative purpose of removing barriers to abortion services. The court affirmed the judgment in favor of the state defendants. View "Bakersfield Crisis Pregnancy Center v. Dept. of Managed Health Care" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Government & Administrative Law
Reneau v. Yoshida & Garcia, Inc.
After being injured in a car accident in June 2020, the plaintiff received medical care at a hospital and presented her Medi-Cal card, establishing her eligibility for California’s Medicaid program. The hospital billed Medi-Cal for some of the services provided but did not submit charges totaling $7,683, which remained unpaid. The hospital, through its attorneys, notified the tortfeasor’s insurance company that it was asserting a statutory hospital lien under California’s Hospital Lien Act (HLA) for the unpaid charges. As a result, the insurance company withheld settlement funds from the plaintiff, who had reached a settlement with the tortfeasor.The plaintiff filed suit in the Superior Court of Los Angeles County, alleging, among other claims, that the hospital’s use of the HLA to assert a lien against her settlement violated the California Unfair Competition Law (UCL) because it conflicted with the Medi-Cal Act. The case was removed to federal court, where the federal debt collection claim was dismissed, and the remaining claims were remanded to state court. The defendants then demurred, and the trial court sustained the demurrer without leave to amend, reasoning that the hospital was authorized under the HLA to assert the lien, even against a Medi-Cal beneficiary, and thus no UCL violation was stated.The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Five, reviewed the judgment. It held that the Medi-Cal Act prohibits providers from seeking reimbursement from Medi-Cal beneficiaries or third-party tortfeasors for covered services, assigning recovery rights instead to the state agency. Consequently, the hospital’s lien was invalid in this context, and the plaintiff had stated a viable UCL claim. The appellate court reversed the judgment and remanded for further proceedings, allowing the UCL claim to proceed. View "Reneau v. Yoshida & Garcia, Inc." on Justia Law
Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions
The dispute centers on an employee, who was hired by a company operating customer service call centers, and who signed an arbitration agreement and a confidentiality agreement as part of her onboarding process. The arbitration agreement was included in a lengthy new hire packet, and the employee understood she was required to sign it to accept the job. The agreement mandated arbitration for nearly all claims between the parties, including those that could arise after employment ended and claims unrelated to employment. The confidentiality agreement included provisions restricting the employee from soliciting colleagues and granted the company the ability to seek injunctive relief for breaches without proving actual damages.After the employee left her position, she filed a class action lawsuit against the company asserting several employment-related claims. The company responded by seeking to compel arbitration based on the previously signed agreement. The Superior Court of Los Angeles County reviewed the motion. It found the arbitration agreement was governed by the Federal Arbitration Act and determined it was a contract of adhesion with a low degree of procedural unconscionability. However, the court found the agreement substantively unconscionable due to its overly broad scope, unlimited duration, and lack of mutuality, following precedent such as Cook v. University of Southern California (2024) 102 Cal.App.5th 312. The court also concluded the confidentiality agreement’s injunctive relief and nonsolicitation clauses were unconscionable. Ultimately, the court denied the motion to compel arbitration, finding the unconscionable terms could not be severed without rewriting the contract.On appeal, the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, Division Eight, affirmed the trial court’s order. The appellate court held that the arbitration agreement, read together with the confidentiality agreement, was permeated with unconscionability that could not be cured by severance, and thus was unenforceable. View "Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions" on Justia Law
Salazar v. CN Motor Co.
A plaintiff, who worked as an hourly employee for an automobile dealership, signed a binding arbitration agreement as part of his hiring process. The agreement required arbitration for nearly all disputes with the employer and a broadly defined set of “affiliates,” including entities not directly related to the employment relationship. It also mandated specific procedures for initiating arbitration, which were more restrictive for the employee than for the employer. The plaintiff later filed a class action in Los Angeles Superior Court alleging various wage and hour violations and unfair competition claims.The Superior Court of Los Angeles County reviewed the employer’s motion to compel arbitration. Although it found the parties had agreed to arbitrate, the court concluded the arbitration agreement was unenforceable due to moderate-to-high procedural unconscionability—primarily because of pressure to sign, the agreement’s presentation in English to a Spanish-speaking employee, and its format. The court also found substantive unconscionability in the agreement’s overbroad scope, lack of mutuality regarding parties and procedures, and infinite duration. It declined to sever the offending terms, instead refusing to enforce the agreement.The Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, Division Eight, reviewed the trial court’s order. It held that while the agreement was adhesive, there was only a low degree of procedural unconscionability. However, it found high substantive unconscionability due to the overbreadth and lack of mutuality in the agreement. The appellate court concluded the unconscionable terms were severable and the trial court erred by not severing them. It reversed the denial of the motion to compel arbitration and directed the trial court to sever the offending terms, enforce arbitration of the plaintiff’s individual employment claims, and address the issue of the class action waiver. View "Salazar v. CN Motor Co." on Justia Law
People v. Guzman
The case concerns a shooting in a Los Angeles park involving rival gangs. Jesus Guzman, associated with Lawndale 13, was accused of killing David Najera, a member of Muertos 13, after an altercation between the gangs the previous night at a hookah bar. The prosecution argued that Guzman and his gang sought revenge for the prior incident, resulting in Najera’s death and the attempted murder of another Muertos member, Portillo. Evidence against Guzman included eyewitness descriptions, video footage, and information from a confidential reliable informant who identified Guzman by his gang moniker and linked his social media account to the crime.The Superior Court of Los Angeles County presided over Guzman’s trial. The jury convicted Guzman of second-degree murder and premeditated attempted murder, finding that a principal—but not Guzman himself—personally and intentionally discharged a firearm causing death. Guzman was sentenced to 22 years to life. The central issue on appeal was Guzman’s challenge to the police search of his social media account, arguing that the affidavit supporting the search warrant lacked sufficient probable cause and did not establish a link between his account and the crime.The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Eight, reviewed the case. The court held that the evidence obtained from Guzman’s social media account was properly admitted because, at a minimum, the good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule applied. The affidavit supporting the search warrant provided a reasonable basis for police to believe the warrant was valid, and it was reasonable to infer that the social media account would contain relevant evidence. The judgment of the trial court was affirmed. View "People v. Guzman" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Criminal Law